New 2026 Columbus market report is out
RL Property Management
The decision, with the work listed out

Should you hire a property manager, or keep self-managing?

Hire a manager when the work, the legal exposure or the distance costs you more than the fee. RL Property Management charges $117 to $184 per unit per month, flat, with a $0 leasing fee. Self-managing one nearby unit can work well.

The short version

  • Flat management runs $117 to $184 per unit per month
  • On a $1,650 rent that is 8.3% of gross rent for the year
  • A year of management costs about the same as 30 days of vacancy at $1,650 rent
  • Roughly 3.5% of rentals reach eviction, litigation or another significant dispute
  • A Franklin County eviction costs $273 in hard costs before anyone's time
  • Portfolio results: 20 median days on market, 72% renewal rate, 96% of rent collected by the 5th
  • Median 6 days to close a repair, 12 days to turn a unit
  • Self-managing is a real option. This page lists the work either way
Before the pitch

What question are you actually answering?

Not "is a property manager worth it" in the abstract. The real question is whether the eight jobs below cost you more, in money, risk and weekends, than a flat fee of $117 to $184 per unit per month. For some owners the answer is no, and we would rather say so on this page than three months into an agreement.

So this page lists the work first. Run it as a checklist against your own property. If you already do all eight, consistently, and the property is close by, you have your answer and you do not need us.

The whole job

What does managing a rental actually involve?

Eight jobs. Each one has a version you can do yourself, and each one has a way it goes wrong.

1.Marketing and leasing the unit

Pricing the unit against live comparables, photographing it, writing the listing, syndicating it to every major portal, answering inquiries within hours rather than days, and running showings. Vacancy is the most expensive thing that happens to a rental, so speed here is worth more than almost anything else you do. Median days on market across our portfolio is 20. Median days from the date a unit is listed to the date a lease is signed, across all units leased in the trailing 12 months.

If you do it yourself Doable if you can answer inquiries during the workday and show the unit on evenings and weekends. Most lost leases are lost to a slow reply, not to a bad property.

2.Screening applicants within fair housing law

Five checks on every adult who will live there: credit, criminal record, verified income, rental history from prior landlords, and public eviction records. The legal requirement is not that you accept everyone, it is that you write the standard down before the first application arrives, apply it identically to every applicant, and can show that you did.

If you do it yourself The highest-risk job on the list for a self-manager, and the one where a casual remark during a showing can create liability even when the written standard is clean. Assistance animals are not pets, so a no-pets policy does not apply to them.

3.Rent collection and late notices

Rent is due on the 1st. In practice many residents pay between the 1st and the 5th, and late fees are assessed after the 5th. The job is an online payment method that works, a ledger that is right, and a notice that goes out on the same day every month whether or not you feel like sending it. 96% of rent across our portfolio is collected by the 5th.

If you do it yourself The part self-managers underestimate is not collecting the rent, it is enforcing the late fee against someone whose kid you know. Consistency is the whole system.

4.Maintenance coordination and after-hours calls

Triaging the request, deciding whether it is an emergency, finding someone who will actually show up, approving the cost, and closing it out. Our in-house labor is $84 per hour plus a $15 trip charge, materials at cost, with no minimum charge. After hours runs 2x on weekday evenings and Saturdays and 3x on Sundays, which is why a 2-hour repair is $183 on a Tuesday and $519 on a Sunday. Median time to close a repair is 6 days.

If you do it yourself This is the job that decides whether self-managing is tolerable. It is not the volume of calls, it is that you cannot predict which weekend they land on.

5.Inspections

A move-in condition report with dated photographs, periodic inspections during the tenancy, and a move-out inspection compared against the move-in record. We inspect quarterly. The move-in report is the document that decides every security deposit dispute, and it is the one self-managers most often skip.

If you do it yourself Cheap to do properly and expensive to have skipped. Photograph every room, every appliance, and the meters, and date-stamp all of it.

6.Ohio landlord-tenant compliance

Lease terms that hold up, the correct notice before an eviction filing, security deposit handling and return, local rental registration where it applies, and the habitability obligations that run for the whole tenancy. Columbus and Franklin County add local requirements on top of Ohio law. Concretely: 24 hours of notice before entry, a three-day notice in the statutory form before an eviction can be filed, and the deposit returned with an itemized statement within 30 days of the tenancy ending and possession being delivered.

If you do it yourself The rules are learnable. The risk is that you learn some of them after you needed them, and the notice you posted incorrectly is the reason a case gets dismissed and refiled.

7.Accounting, statements and 1099s

Separating security deposits from operating funds, tracking income and expense by property so your return is defensible, issuing owner statements, and filing the year-end information returns for contractors you paid. We disburse owner funds on the 10th of each month, about 2 to 3 business days to appear in your account, with monthly statements and a real-time owner portal. A landlord who pays an unincorporated contractor $600 or more in a year files a 1099-NEC, due to both the contractor and the IRS by January 31.

If you do it yourself A separate bank account per entity and a real bookkeeping file, from day one. Retrofitting this in April is worse than doing it in January.

8.Evictions

Roughly 3.5% of rentals reach eviction, litigation or another significant dispute. In Franklin County the hard cost is $273: $150 to the eviction attorney for filing and up to two court appearances, and $123 to the county for the Eviction Complaint. If the resident has not left after judgment, a tag and setout adds $80 to the county. We charge $199 to run the process and $250 if a setout is required.

If you do it yourself You can file yourself. What you cannot do is unwind a defective notice, and the lost month while you refile usually costs more than the attorney would have.

The arithmetic

What does a property manager cost against what a rental earns?

A year of flat management on Plan Two at $137 per unit per month, set against a year of gross rent, and against the vacancy it would take to cost the same amount. Daily rent is monthly rent divided by 30.

Annual management fee against annual gross rent, at three Columbus rents
Monthly rent Gross rent, 12 months Management, 12 months Share of gross rent Equivalent vacant days
$1,200 $14,400 $1,644 11.4% 41
$1,650 $19,800 $1,644 8.3% 30
$2,100 $25,200 $1,644 6.5% 23

Read the last column carefully, because it cuts both ways. At $1,650 rent, a full year of management costs what 30 vacant days cost. If a manager leases your unit that much faster than you would, the fee is paid for. If it does not, it is not. Median days on market across our portfolio is 20 and median days to turn a unit is 12.

We deliberately do not publish an hours-per-unit-per-month figure for self-management. The numbers circulating online for this are not traceable, and putting one here would make every other number on the page less trustworthy.

Where we are not the answer

When does self-managing make sense?

When most of these are true at the same time. One or two is not enough.

  • One unit, close to where you live, that you can reach in fifteen minutes.
  • A long-tenured resident who pays on time and asks for very little.
  • A schedule with real flexibility, so a Tuesday morning showing is not a problem.
  • Genuine comfort with the legal side, or a lawyer you already use for the lease and notices.
  • A rent low enough that a management fee is a large share of the income. Run that number before anything else.

That last one deserves the arithmetic. On Plan Two at $137, management is 11.4% of gross rent at $1,200 and 6.5% at $2,100. The lower the rent, the larger the bite, which is the strongest single argument for self-managing a low-rent unit you live near.

The other direction

When should you stop self-managing?

Any one of these is a reason to get a quote. Three of them together is a reason to move now.

  • You live somewhere else, or you are about to.
  • You own more than a couple of units, or you intend to.
  • You are already behind on the paperwork, the inspections or the late notices.
  • A resident stopped paying and you have not sent anything in writing yet.
  • The property has sat vacant longer than you expected and you are not sure why.
  • You have started making exceptions to your own rules for people you like.

The last one is the quiet killer. Every self-managing owner who ends up in a bad eviction started by making one reasonable exception for someone they liked. A written standard exists so that decision is already made before you have to make it.

If you do hand it over

What does the flat fee commit us to?

These are the parts most agreements leave vague, written down.

Owner funds disbursed on the 10th

Rent is disbursed electronically on the 10th of each month. It takes about 2 to 3 business days to reach your account.

Management fees credited after 60 days of vacancy

If a property has been listed for rent longer than 60 days, we proactively credit management fees back to your account.

No trip charge minimum

There is no minimum charge on maintenance work, and materials are provided at cost.

Project management fee waived on insurance claims

If you hire us to manage a property or casualty insurance claim, the 15% project management fee is waived on that work.

Pet damage covered above the deposit

If an approved pet causes damage beyond normal wear and tear and the cost exceeds the security deposit, we cover the difference up to $4,000.

The complete fee schedule, including every situational charge, is on the pricing page. If a charge is not on that list, we do not make it.

Real answers

Self-managing questions

Should I hire a property manager?

Hire one when the work, the legal exposure or the distance costs you more than the fee. RL Property Management charges $117 to $184 per unit per month with a $0 leasing fee, which on a $1,650 rent is 8.3% of gross rent for the year. Self-managing a single nearby unit with a stable resident is a reasonable choice. Managing several units remotely, while working full time, usually is not.

Is a property manager worth it for one rental property?

Sometimes. The honest test is arithmetic plus tolerance. A year of management on Plan Two costs about the same as 30 days of vacancy at $1,650 rent, so if a manager leases the unit meaningfully faster, or renews a resident you would have lost, the fee can pay for itself. If the unit is around the corner, the resident is long-tenured, and the paperwork is current, self-managing that one property is defensible.

How many hours does it take to self-manage a rental property?

It depends on the property, the resident and the month, and the hours-per-unit figures circulated online are not traceable to any published study. What is predictable is the shape rather than the total: quiet months are close to zero, and a turn, a major repair or a nonpaying resident consumes far more time than a year of quiet ones.

What does a property manager actually do?

Eight jobs: marketing and leasing, screening applicants within fair housing law, rent collection and late notices, maintenance coordination including after-hours emergencies, inspections, Ohio landlord-tenant compliance, accounting and year-end reporting, and evictions when they are needed. Each of those is listed out on this page so you can run them yourself if you decide to.

What is the most expensive mistake a self-managing landlord makes?

Screening loosely, and then acting slowly when it goes wrong. A resident who stops paying in month three costs the unpaid rent, the $273 eviction hard cost in Franklin County, the vacancy while the unit is turned, and the repairs. Roughly 3.5% of rentals reach eviction, litigation or another significant dispute, so the question is not whether it happens, it is what your process does when it does.

Can I self-manage from out of state?

You can, and the failure mode is predictable: you end up dependent on whichever contractor answers the phone, with nobody who has physically seen the property since the last resident moved in. Remote self-management works when you have a trusted local person who will walk the unit. Without that, the distance is the problem, not the workload.

What does it cost to switch from self-managing to a manager?

Nothing to start on an occupied unit: our startup fee is $0. On a vacant unit the fee varies by unit count and plan and is quoted in writing before you sign. A maintenance reserve of $350 to $1,500 per unit is held on your account so routine repairs do not wait on a funding request, and it stays your money.

Will a property manager get me more rent?

Not automatically, and any manager who promises that is guessing. What a manager changes is time on market, renewal rate and collection discipline. Across our portfolio that runs 20 median days on market, a 72% renewal rate, 91% occupancy and 96% of rent collected by the 5th. Ask any manager for their numbers and the definition behind each one.

What should I do first if I want to compare the two?

Price the property honestly, then run the vacancy math. A free rent evaluation gives you a written rent range and the comparables behind it, and it is yours to keep whether you hire us, hire someone else or keep managing it yourself. Portfolio medians across the 700+ units we manage are $1,300 for a 2 bed and $1,708 for a 3 bed.

General information about property management practice in Central Ohio, not legal advice. Statutes and local ordinances change, and your own situation may differ.

Last verified September 2026. Reviewed by Peter Lohmann, Principal Broker and CEO.

Get the numbers before you decide

A free written rent evaluation gives you a rent range and the comparables behind it. It is yours to keep whether you hire us, hire someone else, or keep managing the property yourself.

Free consultation Call